At the beginning of the chapter in the Allyn and Bacon text is a quote by Rodney Kilcup, who is later introduced as a history professor, which states that the most important part of writing is having an interesting question. He compares it to other parts of the writing such as research and grammar. A good question opens the possibility for a great piece of writing, but it is the answer, either by the author or the reader, that makes the writing great. A good piece of writing is really based on the effectiveness of the writer at expressing their ideas in the way that they want to. Whether it be in a vague way that leaves more questions than it answers, or a piece that answers a questions so completely that it is inarguable.
I do agree with his idea that a good question is the basis for a good piece of writing, but does not make a writing good. Kilcup does acknowledge that other parts of writing "may have their place." All parts of writing have a very important role in making a piece good, the execution of explaining and answering the question is just as important as the questions actually existing.
No comments:
Post a Comment