Wednesday, February 8, 2012
Wednesday, February 1, 2012
thoughts
I find it extremely ironic that after reading the essay Visible Man Ethics in a world without secrets by Peter Singer, we posted our summaries on a blog operated by Google, the largest data collection company in the history of the human race. While I do not care much about this, I wonder what Peter Singer would say about this. Google is a company that, while providing extremely useful and money saving tools at no monetary cost to the user, makes it money by tracking your use of all these tools and knows more things about you than you remember. It takes this information and sells highly customized advertising spots to advertisers. This is a perfect example of how desensitized we are to the idea of sharing our thoughts, ideas, and personal information online.
I also recently read that the Library of Congress has a digital record of all public tweets. It does make sense that they would record the tweets as a record of the culture of our time, but the fact that they are able to record all the public tweets in the world without the people knowing is a bit scary. It is the people’s responsibility to know that their tweets are public to the whole world and that they can be recorded by whoever, whenever. This is a pretty similar idea to the Panopticon, where the inmates would know that they could be watched at any time, but not know when or who is doing the watching.
Visible Man Summary
The Panopticon was an eighteenth century design for a prison, which allowed guards to observe the inmates without their knowledge. While this design was never actually built, the ideas behind the structure have been integrated into our everyday lives. As Peter Singer describes, the Panopticon is only the beginning of the overly public world we live in today.
Singer states that privacy is a very western value to begin with, and that many cultures feel uncomfortable with privacy. American’s with money enjoy buying large homes with private spaces dedicated to each person. In other cultures, however, it is undesirable to be alone, so relatives may all sleep in the same room and some may go to such extremes as adopting a child in order to rid themselves of their privacy. Singer then connects this to the clothing differences of women decades ago and women today. Women purposefully gave up privacy even though there was a risk involved, but as more and more women did it, the risk lessened. Singer points out that Facebook is a prime example the changing value of privacy. Over half a billion people are now a part of Facebook, and give away their privacy in order to interact with others. Many cities have now installed cameras with the intention of reducing crime. After addressing the world’s devaluation of privacy, Singer argues that this information we make so publicly available and tag our names, birthdays, and other identifying data to makes us vulnerable to being manipulated. Groups such as law enforcement, corporations, and overly controlling governments now have access to this information and may use it against us. Singer also points out that people have the power to monitor in retaliation, such as the famous Rodney King beating case, where a bystander recorded the police beating Rodney King. The courts later ruled in King’s favor, granting a victory for the public. Additionally Singer also mentions the public victory such as the WikiLeaks and it’s effects on the government.